top of page

Who Is Responsible When Satellites Collide? The Legal Battle Over Space Debris and the Future of Space Liability

Writer: Manoj Ambat
Manoj Ambat
Nov 14
20 min read


Two satellites collide in orbit above Earth, scattering debris and illustrating the legal challenges of space liability.


As Earth's orbit becomes increasingly crowded with operational satellites, abandoned spacecraft and fragments of orbital debris, a difficult question is emerging: who bears legal responsibility when one space object damages another? International space law has an answer, but it may not be adequate for the commercial space age.


Introduction: The Growing Legal Problem Above Earth

Outer space was once regarded as an arena dominated almost exclusively by governments. The launch of satellites, the exploration of celestial bodies and the establishment of orbital infrastructure were activities undertaken primarily by a handful of technologically advanced nations. The legal framework governing these activities was consequently developed around the assumption that States would remain the principal actors in space.


That assumption is rapidly becoming outdated.


Commercial satellite operators, private launch companies, telecommunications corporations and emerging space enterprises are transforming Earth's orbital environment. Thousands of operational satellites now support navigation, communications, weather forecasting, financial transactions, military surveillance and essential civilian infrastructure. The expansion of satellite constellations has made space increasingly important to the functioning of modern societies.


But this expansion has created another problem: space debris.


Defunct satellites, abandoned rocket stages, fragments from accidental collisions and debris generated by destructive anti-satellite tests remain in orbit. Unlike objects on Earth, these fragments cannot simply be collected through conventional waste-management systems. Some travel at extremely high velocities, making even relatively small fragments capable of damaging or destroying operational spacecraft.


A collision between two satellites could disrupt communications, compromise navigation systems, damage strategically important infrastructure or generate thousands of additional fragments. The consequences may extend beyond the commercial interests of the satellite operators involved.


The problem is therefore no longer exclusively scientific or technological. It is a question of international law.


If a privately operated satellite collides with another country's spacecraft, which State is responsible? What happens when the collision involves an abandoned satellite whose operator no longer exists? Can a company be held directly accountable under international space law? Who pays for the destruction of a satellite worth hundreds of millions of dollars?


The answers lie principally in the international space treaties developed during the twentieth century. However, the growing commercialisation of space is exposing significant limitations in this legal framework.


1. The International Legal Foundation: The Outer Space Treaty of 1967

The starting point for understanding space liability is the Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies, commonly known as the Outer Space Treaty of 1967.


The treaty established the foundational principles governing the conduct of States in outer space. Four provisions are particularly important.


Article II: Non-appropriation of outer space


Article II prohibits national appropriation of outer space, including the Moon and other celestial bodies, through claims of sovereignty, occupation or any other means. States cannot establish territorial sovereignty over orbital regions merely by placing satellites there.


Article VI: International responsibility for national space activities


Article VI establishes that States bear international responsibility for national activities in outer space, irrespective of whether those activities are conducted by governmental agencies or non-governmental entities.


A private company may own a satellite, design its mission, operate its communication systems and generate revenue from its services. Nevertheless, the international responsibility of the relevant State does not automatically disappear merely because the activity is commercially operated.


Article VI also requires the activities of non-governmental entities in outer space to receive authorisation and continuing supervision from the appropriate State. Governments cannot simply treat commercial space operations as activities entirely outside their regulatory jurisdiction.


Article VII: International liability for damage


Article VII establishes the international liability of States that launch or procure the launching of a space object, as well as States from whose territory or facilities an object is launched. The provision extends to damage caused by the space object or its component parts on Earth, in airspace or in outer space.


Responsibility under Article VI concerns the obligation of States to ensure that national space activities comply with the treaty. Liability under Article VII concerns the obligation to provide compensation when legally recognised damage occurs.


Article VIII: Jurisdiction, control and ownership


Article VIII provides that a State on whose registry a space object is carried retains jurisdiction and control over that object and its personnel while in outer space or on a celestial body. Ownership is not affected merely because a space object is located in outer space.


This provision becomes particularly important when spacecraft become inactive or are abandoned. The cessation of a satellite's operational life does not automatically mean that its legal ownership or the associated jurisdictional connections disappear.


2. The Liability Convention of 1972: Who Pays for Damage?

The Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects, 1972, commonly known as the Liability Convention, elaborates the liability principles contained in Article VII of the Outer Space Treaty. It establishes an important distinction between damage occurring on Earth and damage occurring elsewhere in outer space.


Absolute liability for damage on Earth


Under Article II, a launching State is absolutely liable to pay compensation for damage caused by its space object on the surface of the Earth or to aircraft in flight. A satellite component falling from orbit and damaging a building, injuring a person or destroying property could potentially trigger this liability. The claimant does not ordinarily need to establish negligence or fault on the part of the launching State.


However, Article VI recognises an important exception. A launching State may be wholly or partially relieved of liability where the damage has resulted, either wholly or partially, from gross negligence or an intentional act or omission by the claimant State or the persons it represents. This exception does not apply where the damage results from activities conducted by the launching State that are contrary to international law.


Fault-based liability for damage in outer space


The legal position changes when damage occurs in outer space. Article III provides that when a space object belonging to one launching State causes damage to the space object of another launching State, the former State is liable only if the damage is due to its fault or the fault of persons for whom it is responsible.


Suppose a privately operated satellite collides with a satellite belonging to another country in low Earth orbit. The affected State cannot simply establish that a collision occurred and automatically demand compensation under the absolute-liability principle applicable to damage on Earth. It must establish fault.


Relevant questions may include: Did the satellite operator fail to maintain adequate collision-avoidance procedures? Was the spacecraft operated in accordance with accepted technical standards? Did the operator possess information about an impending collision? Was a collision-avoidance manoeuvre technically possible? Did the operator fail to communicate relevant orbital information?


The Convention does not provide a comprehensive definition of fault for every possible orbital collision scenario. Determining responsibility may therefore involve complicated technical investigations and difficult questions of evidence.


Article IV: When one collision damages a third State




Article IV addresses an especially important situation: a collision between space objects belonging to two launching States generates debris that subsequently damages the space object of a third State.


In such circumstances, the two launching States may be jointly and severally liable to the third State, subject to the applicable fault requirements. This provision is particularly relevant to the possibility of cascading orbital collisions. An initial collision may create fragments that subsequently damage several unrelated spacecraft. The legal consequences may therefore extend beyond the States and operators directly involved in the original accident.


Multiple launching States


Under the Convention, a launching State may include a State that launches a space object, a State that procures its launch, a State from whose territory the object is launched, or a State from whose facility the object is launched.


A commercial satellite may therefore involve several jurisdictions. For example, a satellite manufactured in one country, financed by a corporation in another country and launched from a third country's spaceport may create multiple potential launching-State connections.


Article VII: An important limitation


The Liability Convention does not apply to damage caused by a space object of a launching State to nationals of that launching State, foreign nationals participating in the operation of that space object, or foreign nationals in the immediate vicinity of the intended launching or recovery area at the invitation of that launching State.


A collision between two Indian space objects resulting in damage to Indian nationals or Indian entities would not ordinarily be a claim under the Convention. The question would principally have to be addressed through applicable Indian domestic law. This is another reason why comprehensive national legislation is necessary.


3. The Unresolved Problem of Space Debris

The Liability Convention appears to provide a legal mechanism for dealing with damage caused by space objects. However, the problem of orbital debris exposes some of its most significant limitations.


Space debris includes defunct satellites, abandoned rocket stages, fragments generated by accidental collisions, debris created through intentional destruction of satellites, small fragments released during spacecraft operations and components of spacecraft that have broken apart over time.


Article I(d) of the Liability Convention defines a space object to include component parts of a space object, as well as its launch vehicle and parts thereof. This provides a basis for treating at least some debris as space objects for liability purposes. However, the precise application of the definition to every category of fragmented or unidentified debris remains a subject of legal debate.


Who is responsible for an abandoned satellite?


Consider a satellite launched several decades ago. Its operator has ceased operations, the spacecraft has lost communication capabilities and its original mission has ended. Years later, the satellite collides with an operational spacecraft. The resulting debris damages additional satellites.


The original launching State may remain relevant under the international liability framework. The fact that a satellite has become inactive does not automatically extinguish the legal significance of its status as a space object.


However, establishing fault in an orbital collision involving an uncontrolled object is considerably more difficult. The operator may no longer exist. The satellite may have been launched before modern collision-avoidance practices became widespread. Its trajectory may have become difficult to predict.


The Convention does not establish a separate, comprehensive compensation mechanism for every situation involving legacy debris.


The problem of unidentified fragments


Another difficulty arises when the debris responsible for damage cannot be identified. Imagine that a commercial satellite suffers a catastrophic collision. Investigators establish that the damage was caused by an external fragment, but cannot reliably identify its original spacecraft or launching State.


The victim may possess evidence of substantial financial loss without having an identifiable respondent against whom an international claim can effectively be pursued.


This is not simply a problem of legal interpretation. It is also a problem of space surveillance, orbital tracking, data preservation and international cooperation. A compensation system is only as effective as its ability to identify the object responsible for the damage.


A real-world illustration: Iridium 33 and Cosmos 2251


On 10 February 2009, two satellites collided at an altitude of approximately 790 kilometres. Iridium 33, an operational American communications satellite, collided with Cosmos 2251, a defunct Russian communications satellite. The collision generated substantial quantities of orbital debris.


The incident raised difficult questions about launching-State connections, fault, ownership and the applicability of the Liability Convention. No formal international liability claim or publicly known dispute-resolution proceeding followed the collision.


The circumstances illustrated an important weakness in the international framework: even when the physical cause of a collision is known, the legal and diplomatic questions surrounding compensation may remain unresolved.


The incident demonstrated that the problem of space debris is not hypothetical. It is already a practical challenge for international space governance.


4. Ownership, Registration and the Legal Identity of Space Objects

An important principle of international space law is that placing an object in outer space does not extinguish ownership.


Article VIII of the Outer Space Treaty provides that a State on whose registry a space object is carried retains jurisdiction and control over that object and its personnel while in outer space or on a celestial body.


The Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space, adopted in 1974 and opened for signature in 1975, further develops the international registration framework. Registration helps establish the identity of space objects and assists in determining which State exercises jurisdiction and control.


However, registration and liability are not interchangeable concepts. A State of registry is not necessarily the only launching State for the purposes of the Liability Convention. A satellite may have several launching-State connections.


Likewise, the fact that a company owns a satellite does not automatically make it the direct respondent under the inter-State claims mechanism established by the Liability Convention.


The modern space industry therefore operates through a division between private operational control and public international legal accountability. This distinction becomes increasingly important when dealing with abandoned spacecraft and legacy debris.


5. The Problem of Enforcing Liability Against Private Space Companies

The Liability Convention was designed primarily as a mechanism through which States could pursue compensation from other States. It does not establish a general international civil court where an injured private satellite operator can directly sue another private satellite operator.


Under Article VIII of the Liability Convention, a claim may be presented by a State that has suffered damage or whose natural or juridical persons have suffered damage. The Convention also provides for claims to be brought in appropriate circumstances by a State in whose territory the damage occurred or by a State of permanent residence of an affected person where the prescribed conditions are met.


Article XI: Domestic remedies remain available


An important qualification is found in Article XI. The presentation of an international claim under the Liability Convention does not require the prior exhaustion of local remedies available to the claimant State or its natural or juridical persons.


The Convention also does not prevent a State or its natural or juridical persons from pursuing claims before the courts or administrative tribunals of a launching State.




This means that the international diplomatic mechanism is not the exclusive avenue of redress. A private satellite operator may have access to domestic litigation, contractual remedies, insurance claims and other legal proceedings, depending on the circumstances and applicable national law.


Nevertheless, the international framework remains State-centred.


Article X: The limitation period


Article X requires a compensation claim to be presented within one year of the date on which the damage occurred or the launching State liable for the damage was identified.


Where the State did not know, and could not reasonably have been expected to know, the relevant facts, the period runs from the date on which those facts became known.


This provision is particularly significant in cases involving unidentified orbital fragments. The difficulty of identifying the source of debris may delay the commencement of the limitation period, but it does not remove the need for timely legal action once the relevant information becomes available.


Article XII: The measure of compensation


Article XII provides that compensation should be determined in accordance with international law and the principles of justice and equity, with the objective of restoring the claimant to the condition that would have existed if the damage had not occurred.


The financial consequences of losing a satellite may extend beyond its manufacturing cost. The destruction may interrupt telecommunications services, disrupt commercial operations and result in substantial financial losses.


The precise extent to which consequential commercial losses can be recovered under the Convention may require difficult legal assessment.


Article XIX: The Claims Commission


Where diplomatic negotiations fail to resolve a claim, Article XIV provides for the establishment of a Claims Commission at the request of either party.


However, under Article XIX(2), the Commission's decision is final and binding only if the parties have agreed that it will be so. Otherwise, the decision is recommendatory.


This is a significant weakness in the dispute-resolution mechanism. A system dealing with potentially enormous commercial losses and strategically important space infrastructure may ultimately produce a recommendation that does not automatically bind the parties.


The absence of a compulsory and universally effective international adjudicatory mechanism is therefore an important issue for future reform.


6. Historical Precedent: The Cosmos 954 Incident

The 1978 re-entry of the Soviet satellite Cosmos 954 provides an important historical example of international space liability.


On 24 January 1978, the nuclear-powered Soviet surveillance satellite Cosmos 954 crashed in Canada's Northwest Territories. The satellite scattered radioactive material over a large area of northern Canada.


The resulting recovery and clean-up operation involved considerable expense and required cooperation between Canada and the United States.


Canada subsequently presented a claim against the Soviet Union. The dispute was ultimately resolved through a bilateral protocol signed on 2 April 1981. Under the agreement, the Soviet Union paid Canada C$3 million in full and final settlement of the matters connected with the satellite's disintegration.


The case is significant because it demonstrated that the international liability framework could provide a basis for diplomatic settlement. However, the matter was resolved through a negotiated agreement. No Claims Commission was established.


Cosmos 954 therefore illustrates both the usefulness and the limitations of the existing framework. It demonstrated that compensation could be obtained through international negotiation, but it did not establish a comprehensive precedent for resolving the more complicated problems of modern commercial satellite collisions.


7. Is Space Debris an International Environmental Law Problem?

Outer space is not subject to national appropriation under Article II of the Outer Space Treaty. States cannot claim sovereignty over outer space merely by occupying or using it. This principle has contributed to the understanding of outer space as an environment requiring international cooperation.


Yet the legal framework has not developed a comprehensive global system of environmental liability for orbital pollution.


Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty requires States to conduct their activities with due regard to the corresponding interests of other States Parties. It also requires States to avoid harmful contamination of outer space and celestial bodies, as well as adverse changes in the environment of the Earth resulting from the introduction of extraterrestrial matter.


The United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (COPUOS) adopted the Space Debris Mitigation Guidelines in 2007. These guidelines address several important objectives:


  1. Limiting debris released during normal spacecraft operations.

  2. Minimising the risk of accidental break-ups.

  3. Reducing the probability of collisions in orbit.

  4. Avoiding intentional destruction and other harmful activities.

  5. Minimising the risk of post-mission fragmentation.

  6. Limiting the long-term presence of spacecraft and rocket stages in low Earth orbit.

  7. Reducing long-term interference with the geostationary orbital region.

The guidelines were endorsed by the United Nations General Assembly through Resolution 62/217. However, they are voluntary guidelines rather than a legally binding international liability regime.


A State may support debris mitigation as a matter of policy and encourage its operators to comply with international best practices. But the existence of voluntary guidelines does not automatically create an enforceable compensation obligation whenever a satellite operator fails to remove an object from orbit.


The Guidelines for the Long-term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities, adopted by COPUOS in 2019, further encourage States to develop national regulatory frameworks, improve space situational awareness and strengthen international cooperation.


These initiatives recognise that the sustainability of the orbital environment requires collective action. Nevertheless, the international community still lacks a universally enforceable system that comprehensively regulates the removal of existing debris and allocates the costs associated with orbital pollution.


The legal question is therefore broader than compensation for collisions. It concerns the responsibility of present generations of space operators to preserve the orbital environment for future generations.


8. India's Position: A Growing Space Industry and an Evolving Legal Framework

India has emerged as an important spacefaring nation. Its space programme has expanded beyond traditional government-led missions into commercial launch services, satellite manufacturing, Earth observation, telecommunications and private-sector innovation.


The Indian Space Policy, 2023, represents a significant development in this transition. It recognises the participation of non-governmental entities in a wide range of space activities, including the establishment and operation of space objects and related ground infrastructure.


The Indian National Space Promotion and Authorisation Centre (IN-SPACe) has an important role in authorising and facilitating private participation in the sector.


The Norms, Guidelines and Procedures for Implementation of Indian Space Policy-2023 in respect of Authorisation of Space Activities, notified on 3 May 2024, provide an operational regulatory framework.


India is a party to the principal international space treaties, including the Outer Space Treaty and the Liability Convention. Its international obligations therefore extend to relevant national space activities, including those undertaken by private entities.


Insurance and indemnification under the existing framework


It would be inaccurate to suggest that India's current regulatory framework contains no provisions concerning insurance or indemnification.


Chapter X of the 2024 IN-SPACe Norms, Guidelines and Procedures addresses liability-related matters. It provides for third-party insurance where considered necessary and requires relevant operators to indemnify IN-SPACe and the Government against specified claims and liabilities arising from authorised activities.




These are important regulatory safeguards. However, they operate within an executive regulatory framework rather than a comprehensive parliamentary statute governing all aspects of space activities.


The distinction is important because the future commercial space industry will require predictable, transparent and legally enforceable rules.


The August 2026 parliamentary disclosure


In a written reply to the Lok Sabha on 5 August 2026, the Minister of State in charge of the Department of Space, Dr Jitendra Singh, disclosed that ISRO had executed 20 collision-avoidance manoeuvres during 2025 and nine more during 2026 up to that date.


The Government also stated that the policy framework and guidelines addressing State liability towards third-party damages arising from Indian space objects, formulated by IN-SPACe, were under consideration.


An important statistical clarification is necessary. ISRO's Indian Space Situational Assessment Report for 2025 records 18 collision-avoidance manoeuvres involving Earth-orbiting satellites: 14 in low Earth orbit and four in geostationary orbit. It separately records two Chandrayaan-2 orbital adjustments undertaken in response to conjunction situations with the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter.


The Government's parliamentary figure of 20 therefore corresponds to the inclusion of these two additional planetary mission adjustments. The figures should not be presented as contradictory without recognising this difference in classification.


The same ISRO report recorded more than 150,000 conjunction alerts analysed for Indian Earth-orbiting satellites during 2025. These figures demonstrate that collision avoidance is already a significant operational responsibility for India's space programme.


The proposed Space Activities Bill


The need for dedicated legislation has also received parliamentary recognition.


In its 410th Report on the Department of Space, presented on 25 March 2026, the Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Science and Technology, Environment, Forests and Climate Change observed that India's space-related activities were not governed by a comprehensive legislative framework and were largely guided by policy documents, vision statements and mission guidelines.


The Committee welcomed the Department of Space's initiative to draft a Bill regulating space activities and emphasised the need for a robust and forward-looking legal framework.


The proposed Space Activities Bill is therefore an important legislative development. However, a draft Bill and a parliamentary committee's endorsement of the need for legislation do not amount to an enacted statute.


Until Parliament enacts a comprehensive law, India's space regulatory architecture will continue to depend substantially on policy instruments, administrative rules and authorisation procedures.


A comprehensive Indian space law should ideally address:


  • Licensing and continuing supervision of private space operators.

  • Allocation of liability between the Government and private entities.

  • Mandatory insurance requirements and financial security.

  • Indemnification of the Government against international claims.

  • Registration and identification of space objects.

  • Collision-avoidance obligations.

  • End-of-life disposal and debris mitigation.

  • Liability arising from satellite failures and orbital collisions.

  • Dispute resolution and compensation for affected third parties.

  • Claims involving damage between Indian space objects and Indian nationals or entities.

Private investors and satellite operators must understand the extent of their financial exposure before undertaking capital-intensive missions. India's ambition to expand its commercial space industry must therefore be accompanied by a corresponding development of its domestic legal architecture.


9. The Strategic Dimension: Space Liability Is Also a National Security Issue

The legal implications of space debris extend beyond commercial losses.


Modern States depend on satellite infrastructure for military communications, intelligence, navigation, missile warning, surveillance and strategic coordination. The destruction or disruption of a satellite may therefore affect national security.


Furthermore, deliberate anti-satellite tests can generate large quantities of orbital debris. An act intended to destroy a military satellite may create risks for civilian spacecraft operated by entirely unrelated countries.


India's own experience makes this issue particularly relevant.


On 27 March 2019, India conducted Mission Shakti, an anti-satellite test in which a direct-ascent interceptor destroyed the Microsat-R target satellite at an altitude of approximately 285 kilometres.


The Government explained that the test was conducted at a relatively low altitude to reduce the long-term persistence of the resulting debris. Indian authorities stated that the majority of the debris would re-enter the atmosphere within a relatively short period.


The test nevertheless generated an international debate about the risks associated with destructive anti-satellite activities and the responsibility of States to avoid harmful contamination of outer space.


Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty is relevant to this discussion. Its due-regard and harmful-contamination obligations are important considerations when evaluating activities that may create persistent orbital debris.


The legal distinction between accidental collisions and deliberate destructive activities is particularly important.


An accidental collision may raise questions of negligence, operational standards and liability under the Liability Convention. An intentional destructive act may additionally engage questions of State responsibility, the prohibition on the use of force where applicable, international security and other treaty obligations.


For India, the issue is especially relevant. As the country expands its satellite infrastructure and develops greater capabilities in space situational awareness, space security and commercial space operations, it must protect not only its own assets but also the long-term sustainability of the orbital environment.


Space law is increasingly becoming an important component of national security law.


10. The Future of Space Liability: What Should International Law Address?

The existing international framework provides a foundation, but it was developed during a period when the number of operational satellites was relatively limited and commercial space activities were considerably less extensive.


The present environment requires a more comprehensive approach. Several reforms deserve consideration.


A. Clearer international standards for orbital fault


The fault-based liability principle under Article III of the Liability Convention requires greater legal and technical clarity.


International standards could identify relevant considerations, including failure to undertake reasonable collision-risk assessments, failure to respond appropriately to credible collision warnings, non-compliance with accepted orbital safety practices, deliberate or reckless creation of debris and failure to maintain adequate operational records.


Such standards would not necessarily eliminate the need for case-specific assessment. They could, however, make the determination of fault more predictable.


B. Compulsory insurance and financial security


Space missions involve substantial financial risks. Compulsory third-party liability insurance, calibrated according to the nature and scale of a mission, could provide greater financial protection.


However, insurance requirements must be realistic. Excessively high premiums or unlimited financial exposure could discourage smaller companies and emerging spacefaring nations from participating in commercial space activities.


A balanced framework should protect third parties without unnecessarily restricting innovation.


C. Better registration and orbital tracking


The identification of debris is fundamental to the enforcement of liability. States should strengthen registration practices, share relevant orbital information and improve international cooperation in space situational awareness.


Better tracking would help identify the source of collisions, establish the sequence of events and preserve evidence for subsequent claims.


D. End-of-life disposal obligations




Satellite operators should be subject to clear end-of-life obligations. These may include controlled de-orbiting, movement to appropriate disposal orbits, passivation of spacecraft and measures to prevent accidental fragmentation.


The costs of responsible disposal should be incorporated into mission planning rather than treated as an optional expense after a satellite has completed its commercial life.


E. A stronger international dispute-resolution mechanism


The existing claims process is primarily diplomatic. Although the Claims Commission offers an additional mechanism, its decisions are not automatically binding unless the parties have agreed to that effect.


The international community should consider more effective mechanisms for resolving disputes involving commercial satellite operators, including appropriate arbitration arrangements and clearer procedures for technical investigations.


F. A framework for legacy debris


Perhaps the most difficult issue is the treatment of debris already present in orbit.


A spacecraft launched decades ago may no longer have an operational owner or an identifiable party capable of carrying out removal.


The international community needs to distinguish between responsibility for creating debris, liability for damage caused by debris and the collective obligation to reduce existing orbital hazards.


These are related but legally distinct questions. A new framework should avoid imposing arbitrary retroactive liability while creating incentives for responsible debris removal and long-term orbital sustainability.


Conclusion: The Next Legal Frontier Is Accountability in Orbit

Humanity's growing presence in outer space has created an unusual legal paradox.


A spacecraft may be privately owned, commercially operated and technologically controlled by a corporation, yet the international legal responsibility associated with its activities may ultimately rest with a State.


The Outer Space Treaty and the Liability Convention established the essential principles governing State responsibility and compensation for damage caused by space objects. Those principles remain relevant. However, they were developed for a different technological and commercial environment.


The expansion of satellite constellations, the growth of private launch services and the increasing density of orbital infrastructure have created challenges that the original treaty framework does not comprehensively resolve.


The Iridium-Cosmos collision demonstrated the practical difficulties of assigning responsibility for orbital accidents. The Cosmos 954 settlement demonstrated that international compensation can be achieved through diplomacy, but also highlighted the absence of a comprehensive adjudicatory system.


Space debris is not simply discarded machinery floating above Earth. It is a continuing source of risk to communications, navigation, scientific research, commercial investment and national security.


The international community must therefore move beyond voluntary debris mitigation and develop more predictable standards for prevention, accountability, compensation and remediation.


For India, the challenge is equally significant. A growing commercial space sector requires a robust domestic legal framework that gives investors confidence, protects third parties and ensures that national activities comply with international obligations.


The proposed Space Activities Bill offers an opportunity to establish that foundation. The challenge will be to ensure that the legislation addresses not only authorisation and commercial participation but also liability, insurance, indemnification, orbital safety and effective remedies.


The future of space exploration will not be determined solely by who can launch the most satellites or reach the most distant destinations.


It will also depend on whether humanity can establish a legal system capable of governing the consequences of its activities in orbit.


The next great challenge in space may not be reaching orbit. It may be establishing who is responsible when things go wrong there.


Related ALI Research

Stay Informed: Subscribe to Ambat Legal Insight

Receive ALI's latest legal research, analysis and perspectives on international law, national security, technology, governance and emerging legal frontiers. Subscribe to the ALI Legal Brief through the subscription facility on our website.


References and Legal Sources

International treaties and instruments

  1. Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, 1967 — Articles II, VI, VII, VIII and IX.

  2. Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects, 1972 — Articles I–XX. UNOOSA treaty text

  3. Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space, adopted in 1974 and opened for signature in 1975.

  4. UN General Assembly Resolution 62/217 (2007) — Space Debris Mitigation Guidelines of COPUOS.

  5. Guidelines for the Long-term Sustainability of Outer Space Activities, COPUOS, 2019.

Indian legal and policy sources

  1. Indian Space Policy, 2023.

  2. IN-SPACe, Norms, Guidelines and Procedures for Implementation of Indian Space Policy-2023 in respect of Authorisation of Space Activities, notified 3 May 2024 — particularly Chapter X.

  3. Department of Space, Government of India — Written reply in Lok Sabha on Collision Avoidance Manoeuvres executed by ISRO, 5 August 2026. PIB release

  4. Indian Space Situational Assessment Report (ISSAR-2025), ISRO, released 8 April 2026.

  5. 410th Report of the Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Science and Technology, Environment, Forests and Climate Change, 25 March 2026 — Space Law section.

Historical and technical sources

  1. Protocol between Canada and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics concerning the settlement of the Cosmos 954 claim, 2 April 1981. UNOOSA settlement record

  2. NASA technical material on the Iridium 33–Cosmos 2251 collision, 2009.

Editorial note: This article is intended for legal information and research. It does not constitute legal advice on any particular space activity, insurance arrangement or international claim.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page